RoverAndOut 1,386 Posted May 22 19 hours ago, BuffaloPhil said: Come on Tebbit! Without pre-empting Biblio's update, I fear I may have bad news for you on the Tebbit front... Well this is unexpectedly exciting! 1 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bibliogryphon 5,519 Posted May 22 1 hour ago, RoverAndOut said: Without pre-empting Biblio's update, I fear I may have bad news for you on the Tebbit front... Well this is unexpectedly exciting! Yes the Hurd/Tebbit trade-off only applied whilst you were tied Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bibliogryphon 5,519 Posted May 23 Following his second unique hit @RoverAndOut must become the favourite to take the title now. As he has two ways of going out 1. John Aniston (ro) 2. Vasily Borisov (to) 3. Irene Camber (to) 4. Kenneth Clarke (ro) 5. Norman Fowler (ro) 6. Tom Gayford (ro) 7. Gordy Giovenelli (to) 8. Roy Hattersley (ro) 9. Douglas Hurd (ro) 10. Nigel Lawson (mc) 11. James Mackay (bp) 12. John Morris (bp) 13. Koji Murofushi (to) 14. Bob Richards (to) 15. Bill Rodgers (bp) 16. Norman Tebbit (ro) 17. Anthony Zerbe (ro) Of the seventeen possible hits to go out Rover now has 8 of them adding two Star Trek actors and another Olympian. Interestingly adding the first and last alphabetically of the Star Trek picks However any of the pennies could go over the cascade so anyone who is mentioned above needs to be thinking about their Game V categories 2 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RoverAndOut 1,386 Posted May 23 3 hours ago, Bibliogryphon said: Following his second unique hit @RoverAndOut must become the favourite to take the title now. As he has two ways of going out 1. John Aniston (ro) 2. Vasily Borisov (to) 3. Irene Camber (to) 4. Kenneth Clarke (ro) 5. Norman Fowler (ro) 6. Tom Gayford (ro) 7. Gordy Giovenelli (to) 8. Roy Hattersley (ro) 9. Douglas Hurd (bp) 10. Nigel Lawson (mc) 11. James Mackay (bp) 12. John Morris (bp) 13. Koji Murofushi (to) 14. Bob Richards (to) 15. Bill Rodgers (bp) 16. Norman Tebbit (ro) 17. Anthony Zerbe (ro) Of the seventeen possible hits to go out Rover now has 8 of them adding two Star Trek actors and another Olympian. Interestingly adding the first and last alphabetically of the Star Trek picks However any of the pennies could go over the cascade so anyone who is mentioned above needs to be thinking about their Game V categories Personally, I do not feel that this has decisively tipped the balance in my favour, though obviously more outs is a positive. Nicking Tebbit from BuffaloPhil may yet be my biggest masterstroke. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RoverAndOut 1,386 Posted May 23 4 minutes ago, RoverAndOut said: Personally, I do not feel that this has decisively tipped the balance in my favour, though obviously more outs is a positive. Nicking Tebbit from BuffaloPhil may yet be my biggest masterstroke. Oh, and whilst not wanting to seem greedy, shouldn't Douglas Hurd be in my outs too..? (Edit: actually, I think you've counted him in my 8 but attached the wrong initials!) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bibliogryphon 5,519 Posted May 23 1 hour ago, RoverAndOut said: Oh, and whilst not wanting to seem greedy, shouldn't Douglas Hurd be in my outs too..? (Edit: actually, I think you've counted him in my 8 but attached the wrong initials!) I think I changed it in the masterlist but that was after I had copied the text Will edit to amend 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BuffaloPhil 127 Posted May 23 Well, I've still got three nonagenarian Lords who can happily pop their clogs before Tebbit please! 1 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Captain Hemlock 186 Posted May 23 Joe Pignatano is a hit for two teams in World Series Champions. https://www.mlb.com/press-release/press-release-joe-pignatano-passes-away 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Toast 10,682 Posted May 23 Oh my, that's put the cat among the pigeons. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RoverAndOut 1,386 Posted May 23 On 12/04/2022 at 00:00, RoverAndOut said: While I'm keen to notch up another win (and fancy my chances as much as any of the other contenders), it did amuse me to realise that if Agnes Keleti (Olympian), Charles Coste (Olympian), Joe Pignatano (Baseball) and David Frankham (Star Trek) all die in short order, that would bring another 7 players (Chilean Way, Death impends, GCReptile, Perhaps, Banana, Spade Cooley and An Fear Baeg) into play with hits in 4 categories, waiting for a Cabinet Minister. Good luck with the tie breaks then, Biblio! Keleti alone would bring 3 more players to one away - and given she's 101, it's not that unfeasible! This game just keeps on delivering. Still, come in Secretary Hurd, your time is up! He was on my list of nightmare names. Good luck, Biblio! 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RoverAndOut 1,386 Posted May 23 15 minutes ago, RoverAndOut said: He was on my list of nightmare names. Good luck, Biblio! Just done some calculating and I don't think it's that horrific, bar bringing another player to 1 away. It makes no difference to @Toast, who's waiting for an Olympian, and I don't think @Perhaps has enough to take any picks from either me or @BuffaloPhil. They have 6 hits and no uniques. Phil has 7 hits and 1 unique, I have 8 hits and 2 uniques. So Hattersley stays with me, Morris and Rodgers stay with Phil and Perhaps can win if either John Nott or Peter Brooke peg it. Of course, if 1 of Perhaps' 2 uniques were to die next, then that would tie him up with Phil and we'd be back in tie breaker split mode! This is great, it reminds me of Round 1, when the winning picks just kept mounting up! 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bibliogryphon 5,519 Posted May 24 14 hours ago, Captain Hemlock said: Joe Pignatano is a hit for two teams in World Series Champions. https://www.mlb.com/press-release/press-release-joe-pignatano-passes-away Indeed Joe Pignatano is the sixth overall hit for both @Toast and @Perhaps For Toast this is just another addition to their tally and does not bring any new ways to win but might be important in deciding later ties For Perhaps this is a first hit in the Baseball category and therefore they are down to needing a British Cabinet Minister to win. Unfortunately these are heavily in demand and a lack of unique leaves Perhaps at a disadvantage as three of his 'outs' are taken by players whose claim trumps them but there are two new outs to add to the list. We are now up to 19 1. John Aniston (ro) 2. Vasily Borisov (to) 3. Peter Brooke (ph) 4. Irene Camber (to) 5. Kenneth Clarke (ro) 6. Norman Fowler (ro) 7. Tom Gayford (ro) 8. Gordy Giovenelli (to) 9. Roy Hattersley (ro) 10. Douglas Hurd (ro) 11. Nigel Lawson (mc) 12. James Mackay (bp) 13. John Morris (bp) 14. Koji Murofushi (to) 15. John Nott (ph) 16. Bob Richards (to) 17. Bill Rodgers (bp) 18. Norman Tebbit (ro) 19. Anthony Zerbe (ro) 1 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bibliogryphon 5,519 Posted May 24 There was almost a whole month gap in hits and then two rapid ones which change the finishing landscape Even so this looks like being one of the shorter games 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BuffaloPhil 127 Posted May 24 On 13/03/2022 at 11:30, Bibliogryphon said: I am inclined to permit this as a hit for the following reasons: 1. The is no evidence that any of those that selected this pick were aware of the status 2. All the due diligence I did at the beginning of the game indicated that they were still alive 3. There was no challenge during the challenge period 4. This is not a unique pick 5. Two of the points recipients are currently in winning positions anyway but this does not immediately increase their winning combinations. 6. The other possible resolutions are potentially very messy or may disproportionately disadvantage one or more players. I will not award the points until tomorrow on the off chance Norman Tebbit comes off his bike a saves me from making a call. If you agree then like react this post if you disagree sad react this post. Comments welcome Just seen (whilst desperately and unsuccessfully checking my other potential hits) that Unger hasn't been crossed off on the masterlist, although it does seem that the points have been awarded - so a minor housekeeping issue. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RoverAndOut 1,386 Posted May 24 As this game gears up towards a conclusion, a big moment in the first Scavenger Hunt with the death of Tory peer Pamela Sharples. Her death is the 5th death in the Lords category for both Rad Guy and good old Deathray, meaning they have completed a whole category and have finally "won", just 4-and-a-half years after the round ended! It also means perennial underdog @time is now the only one of the 15 players in Round 1 to have not yet completed by one of the 3 methods of victory. He is awaiting any of his 5 Doctor Who picks (if you're interested: Tony Caunter, Julian Glover, Frazer Hines, Milton Johns and Jean Marsh) dropping to complete the set. As for @Bibliogryphon's suggestion this current R4 is one of the shorter games: we've surpassed R3's little more than 8 months, and will reach a year should we get to the end of this month, but R1 took 18 months and R2 over 2 years! So yes, on for being the second shortest, but it all just adds to the unpredictability of the Scavenger Hunt! 2 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
time 4,852 Posted May 24 2 hours ago, RoverAndOut said: As this game gears up towards a conclusion, a big moment in the first Scavenger Hunt with the death of Tory peer Pamela Sharples. Her death is the 5th death in the Lords category for both Rad Guy and good old Deathray, meaning they have completed a whole category and have finally "won", just 4-and-a-half years after the round ended! It also means perennial underdog @time is now the only one of the 15 players in Round 1 to have not yet completed by one of the 3 methods of victory. He is awaiting any of his 5 Doctor Who picks (if you're interested: Tony Caunter, Julian Glover, Frazer Hines, Milton Johns and Jean Marsh) dropping to complete the set. As for @Bibliogryphon's suggestion this current R4 is one of the shorter games: we've surpassed R3's little more than 8 months, and will reach a year should we get to the end of this month, but R1 took 18 months and R2 over 2 years! So yes, on for being the second shortest, but it all just adds to the unpredictability of the Scavenger Hunt! Current ages 84, 87, 77, 84 & 87 respectively; it's almost as if being picked by me assures longevity, whatever health issues you may face! 1 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RoverAndOut 1,386 Posted May 24 39 minutes ago, time said: Current ages 84, 87, 77, 84 & 87 respectively; it's almost as if being picked by me assures longevity, whatever health issues you may face! To be fair, I've got Jean Marsh on my team. The fact she's still going having ended her involvement in the Upstairs Downstairs revival due to ill health a decade ago is astonishing! 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gcreptile 6,104 Posted June 8 On 01/06/2021 at 19:49, Perhaps said: I managed to bag 2 uniques so without the third they're both useless. Annoyingly 2 of my subs (Gene Roberts for Pullitzer Prize winners and Isaac Berger for gold medalists) would have been unique. Isaac Berger would have been a hit: https://fitnessvolt.com/weightlifter-isaac-berger-died/ 2 1 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites