Who is not Deathlist worthy?

[Sean 6,005]

Thread for picks we think the committee should discard.Mine are Greg Gilbert Devin Lima and John Bain.

[Sean 6,005]

Worthy# can some kind mod please correct this Diane Abbott level typo?

[CaptainChorizo 1,917]

Patrick Cryne and Dean Francis,though both will get QO

 

Although I think he is exaggerating about how ill he is,  Total Biscuit/John Bain is more than DL worthy. The kids they love their gaming and he is Pauline Kael/Roger Ebert level of being one of the face of pc game critics.

[msc 17,806]

So this is the thread to point to when folk ask why the 2018 list is full of 90 year old comedians and football owners?

[Sean 6,005]

Cryne I agree with but Francis I think could get a place like Christie did.

[Sean 6,005]

1 minute ago, msc said:

So this is the thread to point to when folk ask why the 2018 list is full of 90 year old comedians and football owners?

Essentially yes.

[Sean 6,005]

Christie set the precedent for Francis.

[msc 17,806]

Just now, Sean said:

Essentially yes.

 

Sinead. Always Sinead.

 

I think Gilbert, Cryne and Francis are Deathlisty if the Cmme say they are! But never Sinead. What a waste of a pick that'd be.

[CaptainChorizo 1,917]

The more I think about it, the more I am all for Devin Lima being placed on the DL.  2018 seems about time to finally have the first DL Hit from the Frosted Tip Generation

[Sean 6,005]

Sinead is Deathlist worthy but not worth a shot as she could last a while.If she is diagnosed with stage 4 pancreatic cancer then she would pass the fame test.

[msc 17,806]

Yes, but until then, Sinead is a complete waste of space.

 

And on top of that, a wasted Deathlist pick.

[Sean 6,005]

The name that I really think the DL have underestimated is Stefan Karl.The guy was part of a highly successful children's show much like John Noakes.

[Joey Russ 7,120]

1 hour ago, CaptainChorizo said:

The more I think about it, the more I am all for Devin Lima being placed on the DL.  2018 seems about time to finally have the first DL Hit from the Frosted Tip Generation

Yeah, but I don't think the deathlist do one hit wonders unless they had a very significant impact elsewhere. Hence why the likes of Peter Sarstedt  and Peter Skellern didn't make it.

[time 7,989]

Who is not Deathlist worthy?

 

Me.

 

I'm unlikely to get a qualifying obit even if I die next year, which hopefully won't happen.

 

Have I got this thread right?