Kill or Save: UK No. 1-hits of the 70s

[Toast 16,140]

14 David Bowie – Space Oddity  -4

12 Donna Summer – I Feel Love  +4

0 Kate Bush – Wuthering Heights  -2

 

Sorry, Kate lovers. Wuthering Heights was a tour de force, but I don't feel it was influential in the way that the Donna Summer/Giorgio Moroder collaboration proved to be. 

Same can be said of Space Oddity, another one-off.

[theoldlady 2,300]

18 David Bowie - Space Oddity +4
6 Donna Summer – I Feel Love -6

 

[Death Impends 7,971]

12 David Bowie - Space Oddity -6
10 Donna Summer – I Feel Love +4

[En Passant 3,741]

What toast said. Looks like we're going to lose to a novelty record ffs - that's just wrong after all this.

I love Bowie, but no.

 

I thought we were better than this.

 

[Bibliogryphon 9,579]

14 Donna Summer – I Feel Love +4

6 David Bowie - Space Oddity -6
 

[wildstorm 297]

18 Donna Summer - I feel Love +4

0 David Bowie - Space Oddity -6

[TQR 14,391]

David Bowie was an icon and a genius, and Space Oddity doesn’t show that off enough IMO. It is a novelty more than a masterpiece; an interesting concept more than an enjoyable listen.

 

Both Heart of Glass and I Feel Love are definitive songs, true icons of new wave and disco. HoG, as a couple of others have said, isn’t even my favourite Blondie song, but fuck me it’s good and its influence is laced throughout the subsequent 45 years of music. On a personal level it takes it, but Donna Summer is definitely a worthy winner.

[En Passant 3,741]

Quality will out in the end.

And despite my misgivings, it did.

 

Loads of great tracks in the last part, so hard to call, but that's really the right decision in my view.

[Toast 16,140]

25 minutes ago, TQR said:

Both Heart of Glass and I Feel Love are definitive songs, true icons of new wave and disco. HoG, as a couple of others have said, isn’t even my favourite Blondie song, but fuck me it’s good and its influence is laced throughout the subsequent 45 years of music. On a personal level it takes it, but Donna Summer is definitely a worthy winner.

 

We have Atomic to look forward to. 

[Book 3,556]

After 80 days of killing and saving, discussing and arguing, laughing and crying, loving and hating - we found our winner, and what a winning song that is: It's the iconic and influencial space disco tune I FEEL LOVE of the divine Donna Summer! Thanks for that! I really appreciate this winning song!

I'm sorry that I don't have the time to present you an elaborated summary of our journey and every Top 25 song, but here is a listing at least:

 

The Grand Final:

 

01. Donna Summer – I feel love

02. David Bowie – Space Oddity

03. Kate Bush – Wuthering Heights

04. Blondie – Heart of glass

05. ABBA – The name of the game

06. Gary Numan – Cars

07. Queen – Bohemian Rhapsody

08. T.Rex – Get it on

09. ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you

10. Suzi Quatro – Devil Gate Drive

11. The Sweet – Blockbuster

12. Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie

13. Alice Cooper – School´s out

14. Simon & Garfunkel – Bridge over troubled water

15. 10CC – I´m not in love

16. Smokey Robinson & The Miracles – Tears of a clown

17. Nilsson – Without you

18. ABBA – Waterloo

19. Don McLean – Vincent

20. Suzi Quatro – Can the can

21. Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

22. Blondie – Sunday Girl

23. ABBA – Fernando

24. Bay City Rollers – Bye bye baby

25. Slade – Coz I luv you

 

Maybe we can start the new year dancing and feeling like Donna Summer - she seems to have much fun in her own song.

So, now shut your eyes, pump up the volume, dance around and let's start 2023 with MUCH LOVE!

 

 

Thank you all for beeing part of this little game and musical journey! It was fucking fun!!!  Thank you!

The 80s are on its way

[justonecornetto 950]

Had a bad feeling that Blondie would be gonners by the time I got up today but happy that HoG was rated 4th best in a very strong list. Well done to Donna Summer a worthy winner.

[Bibliogryphon 9,579]

59 minutes ago, Book said:

After 80 days of killing and saving, discussing and arguing, laughing and crying, loving and hating - we found our winner, and what a winning song that is: It's the iconic and influencial space disco tune I FEEL LOVE of the divine Donna Summer! Thanks for that! I really appreciate this winning song!

I'm sorry that I don't have the time to present you an elaborated summary of our journey and every Top 25 song, but here is a listing at least:

 

The Grand Final:

 

01. Donna Summer – I feel love

02. David Bowie – Space Oddity

03. Kate Bush – Wuthering Heights

04. Blondie – Heart of glass

05. ABBA – The name of the game

06. Gary Numan – Cars

07. Queen – Bohemian Rhapsody

08. T.Rex – Get it on

09. ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you

10. Suzi Quatro – Devil Gate Drive

11. The Sweet – Blockbuster

12. Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie

13. Alice Cooper – School´s out

14. Simon & Garfunkel – Bridge over troubled water

15. 10CC – I´m not in love

16. Smokey Robinson & The Miracles – Tears of a clown

17. Nilsson – Without you

18. ABBA – Waterloo

19. Don McLean – Vincent

20. Suzi Quatro – Can the can

21. Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

22. Blondie – Sunday Girl

23. ABBA – Fernando

24. Bay City Rollers – Bye bye baby

25. Slade – Coz I luv you

 

Maybe we can start the new year dancing and feeling like Donna Summer - she seems to have much fun in her own song.

So, now shut your eyes, pump up the volume, dance around and let's start 2023 with MUCH LOVE!

 

 

Thank you all for beeing part of this little game and musical journey! It was fucking fun!!!  Thank you!

The 80s are on its way

Thank you for running this. It was so much fun. Naturally I was routing for Kate Bush but the last four would all have been worthy winners

 

What can I say we have excellent taste

[TQR 14,391]

This is great fun Book, thanks so much for bringing it to us and I can’t wait for the next game!

[Book 3,556]

New round starts here:

 

[theoldlady 2,300]

@BookThanks for all the work you did for this fun game. Wonderful idea. Looking forward to the 1980s!

[time 8,599]

Not the result I was looking for, but the people have spoken (and be honest, its not the first time the people have been wrong). Bring on the 80s!

[ladyfiona 2,580]

@Book thanks for running this despite Donna Summer being eventual winner. Bring on the 80s.

[Book 3,556]

5 minutes ago, ladyfiona said:

@Book thanks for running this despite Donna Summer being eventual winner. Bring on the 80s.

 

You found them, I see, enjoy!