Kill or Save: UK No.2 Hits of the 90s

[Toast 16,112]

11 hours ago, RoverAndOut said:

We're getting there with this list. N-Trance are turning on the Christmas lights one town across from us this year. People of a certain age seem filled with nostalgia. I am not of that age.

 

Neither am I and I don't even remember that song, but I liked it when I listened to it. 

Nearly everything I liked has been voted out now.

[BuffaloPhil 922]

54 Pulp — Common People

53 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

44 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm 

37 Ace Of Base — The Sign 

33 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

27 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night -6

26 Pulp — Mis-Shapes / Sorted For E's And Wizz  +4

25 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

25 Queen — Heaven For Everyone

22 Bon Jovi — Always

19 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

18 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night

15 Alex Party — Don't Give Me Your Life

[Drewsky1211 4,721]

10/28/2023

 

54 Pulp — Common People

53 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

44 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm 

40 Ace Of Base — The Sign +3

33 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night +1

26 Pulp — Mis-Shapes / Sorted For E's And Wizz

25 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

25 Queen — Heaven For Everyone

22 Bon Jovi — Always

19 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

15 Alex Party — Don't Give Me Your Life

12 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night -6

[TQR 14,382]

I’m also staggered that N-Trance has been binned. It’s absolutely class! You cannot tell me that Bon fucking Jovi is a more rousing and enjoyable listen. 

 

Are people just voting things down because they’re not in the top half of the list? That’s not the way to go. Makes me wonder if the result would be different if the kills and assists weren’t counted?

[lilham 752]

October 28th at 804am

 

54 Pulp — Common People

53 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

44 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm 

40 Ace Of Base — The Sign

37 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me +4

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

26 Pulp — Mis-Shapes / Sorted For E's And Wizz

25 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

25 Queen — Heaven For Everyone

22 Bon Jovi — Always

19 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

12 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night

9 Alex Party — Don't Give Me Your Life -6

[Toast 16,112]

34 minutes ago, TQR said:

I’m also staggered that N-Trance has been binned. It’s absolutely class! You cannot tell me that Bon fucking Jovi is a more rousing and enjoyable listen.

Are people just voting things down because they’re not in the top half of the list? That’s not the way to go. Makes me wonder if the result would be different if the kills and assists weren’t counted?

 

Bon Jovi is a decent power ballad.  It's an entirely different genre so there's no comparison.

I do think some people are voting songs down because they are near the bottom, and I will do this but only if I've listened to them and not liked them.  I don't do it indiscriminately.

[TQR 14,382]

Well look, this isn’t (completely) a dictatorship; what do people think about trying this without the score counts? I feel as if the kill counts turn the game more into a maths exercise than an expression of opinion. Let me know what you think.

[diego 1,978]

October 28th at 10:20h

 

54 Pulp — Common People

53 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

44 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm 

37 Ace Of Base — The Sign -3

37 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

26 Pulp — Mis-Shapes / Sorted For E's And Wizz

25 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

25 Queen — Heaven For Everyone

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'+4

22 Bon Jovi — Always

12 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night

6 Alex Party — Don't Give Me Your Life -3

[theoldlady 2,294]

 

 October 28th 

 

54 Pulp — Common People

53 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

48 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm +4

37 Ace Of Base — The Sign 

37 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

26 Pulp — Mis-Shapes / Sorted For E's And Wizz

25 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

25 Queen — Heaven For Everyone

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

22 Bon Jovi — Always

12 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night

00 Alex Party — Don't Give Me Your Life -6

 

Thank you @diego

[Toast 16,112]

56 minutes ago, TQR said:

Well look, this isn’t (completely) a dictatorship; what do people think about trying this without the score counts? I feel as if the kill counts turn the game more into a maths exercise than an expression of opinion. Let me know what you think.

 

I think there's only one player who cares about kill counts

[TQR 14,382]

Oh I don’t know. I’ll have a think about either killing the scoreboards or adjusting the rules. Maybe when I’m not pissed off at two brilliant songs in a row having been given the boot.

[Root Inspector 184]

28th October

 

54 Pulp — Common People

53 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

48 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

37 Ace Of Base — The Sign 

37 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

26 Pulp — Mis-Shapes / Sorted For E's And Wizz

25 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

22 Bon Jovi — Always

19 Queen — Heaven For Everyone -6

16 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night +4

 

I know Another Night is doomed but I'll do what I can for it.

[RoverAndOut 4,745]

4 hours ago, TQR said:

I’m also staggered that N-Trance has been binned. It’s absolutely class! You cannot tell me that Bon fucking Jovi is a more rousing and enjoyable listen. 

 

Are people just voting things down because they’re not in the top half of the list? That’s not the way to go. Makes me wonder if the result would be different if the kills and assists weren’t counted?

 

The kills/assists makes very little difference to how I play the game. If something's "killable" and its not reasonably likely to make my final 5 of what's left, then I'm happy to get rid. If it is, then I try and save it, even if it's in the killable zone. I don't think it's a simple as people looking to get rid of a song, I've tried to set that in motion before and failed - I think what happens is someone downvotes something, the next person thinks "yeah, I'm not fussed about that either" and adds their -6 to it and that happens a few times in a row and it gets removed. If a song has support, it wouldn't go - and yes, it can be that the song's in the wrong place at the wrong time of day, but that's part of the game. As proved last night, I would not have got rid of the Alex Party song just yet, I like that one.

 

I don't mind what's left on the whole, I might border on sacrilegious and suggest Mis-Shapes is the better Pulp song...

[Paul Bearer 6,099]

5 hours ago, TQR said:

Well look, this isn’t (completely) a dictatorship; what do people think about trying this without the score counts? I feel as if the kill counts turn the game more into a maths exercise than an expression of opinion. Let me know what you think.

I'm sure the scores would be completely different if people actually genuinely voted for the songs they liked or disliked and not just to make a name for themselves by only voting for the song with 6 or less points.  If I don't like a song, down it goes. It's just a bonus if it has a score of 6 or less at the time of the vote. 

[Paul Bearer 6,099]

28/10/23 19:09 hrs 

 

54 Pulp — Common People

53 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

48 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

37 Ace Of Base — The Sign 

37 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

26 Bon Jovi - Always +4

25 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

20 Pulp - Mis-Shapes / Sorted for E's and Wizz -6

19 Queen — Heaven For Everyone 

16 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night 

[TQR 14,382]

1 hour ago, RoverAndOut said:

 

The kills/assists makes very little difference to how I play the game. If something's "killable" and its not reasonably likely to make my final 5 of what's left, then I'm happy to get rid. If it is, then I try and save it, even if it's in the killable zone. I don't think it's a simple as people looking to get rid of a song, I've tried to set that in motion before and failed - I think what happens is someone downvotes something, the next person thinks "yeah, I'm not fussed about that either" and adds their -6 to it and that happens a few times in a row and it gets removed. If a song has support, it wouldn't go - and yes, it can be that the song's in the wrong place at the wrong time of day, but that's part of the game. As proved last night, I would not have got rid of the Alex Party song just yet, I like that one.

 

I don't mind what's left on the whole, I might border on sacrilegious and suggest Mis-Shapes is the better Pulp song...

It seems to affect some and not others. Food for thought…

 

Completely agree re: Pulp. I’d go as far as to say Common People ain’t all that.

[time 8,581]

This "kill" and "assist" thing is the main reason I stopped participating. In my opinion, certain people are voting with the intention of getting on the scoreboard at the end of the game, rather than voting on what they actually think of the song.

 

Agree about Pulp, Common People is not their best song, and their version is not the best version.

[TQR 14,382]

Sun 29 Oct

 

54 Pulp — Common People

53 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

48 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

37 Ace Of Base — The Sign 

37 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

29 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads +4

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

20 Pulp - Mis-Shapes / Sorted for E's and Wizz

20 Bon Jovi - Always -6

19 Queen — Heaven For Everyone 

16 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night

[RoverAndOut 4,745]

Sun 29 Oct

 

54 Pulp — Common People

53 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

48 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

37 Ace Of Base — The Sign 

37 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

29 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

21 Pulp - Mis-Shapes / Sorted for E's and Wizz +1

21 Bon Jovi - Always +1

21 Queen — Heaven For Everyone +2

10 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night -6

[Clorox Bleachman 2,400]

29/10/2023

 

56 Pulp — Common People +2

55 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me +2

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

48 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

37 Ace Of Base — The Sign 

37 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

29 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

21 Pulp - Mis-Shapes / Sorted for E's and Wizz

21 Bon Jovi - Always

21 Queen — Heaven For Everyone

04 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night -6

[TQR 14,382]

1 hour ago, time said:

In my opinion, certain people are voting with the intention of getting on the scoreboard at the end of the game, rather than voting on what they actually think of the song.

I agree. I get the idea of moving the game on, but this is an opinion poll. There might be some tactics to protect or eject a song one feels strongly about but really that’s the only time one might change their vote.

 

I’m scrapping the scoreboard.

[ladyfiona 2,570]

29th October

 

59 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me +4

56 Pulp — Common People

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

48 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

37 Ace Of Base — The Sign 

35 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me -2

29 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

21 Pulp - Mis-Shapes / Sorted for E's and Wizz

21 Bon Jovi - Always

21 Queen — Heaven For Everyone

 

 

00 MC Sar & The Real McCoy — Another Night -4

[Root Inspector 184]

29th October

 

59 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me

56 Pulp — Common People

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

48 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm

41 Ace Of Base — The Sign +4

37 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

29 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

21 Pulp - Mis-Shapes / Sorted for E's and Wizz

21 Bon Jovi - Always

15 Queen — Heaven For Everyone -6

[ladyfiona 2,570]

I forgot to give -2 to someone so hang on.

 

Edit - Ok you can continue.

[Toast 16,112]

Sun 29 Oct

 

63 Kylie Minogue — Confide In Me  +4

56 Pulp — Common People

48 Supergrass — Alright / Time

42 Crash Test Dummies — Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm  -6

41 Ace Of Base — The Sign

35 U2 — Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me 

29 The Stone Roses — Love Spreads

28 Corona — The Rhythm Of The Night

23 Annie Lennox — No More 'I Love You's'

21 Pulp - Mis-Shapes / Sorted for E's and Wizz

21 Bon Jovi - Always

15 Queen — Heaven For Everyone

 

Adjusted the U2 score