thefunkyfaz 51 Posted January 2, 2013 Well, last year was monumentally unsuccessful for me - joint 193rd for one team (4/20) and joint 322nd for t'other (3/20). Very poo-er. I think I've chosen better this year but the competition looks dangerously, erm, dangerous - some very good teams here. My picks for 2013 are..oh, just read the signature below... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Whitehouse 872 Posted January 2, 2013 Were my lists confirmed? I've sent them three days ago but haven't recieved a confirmation. Edit: Didn't see clear. I got a reply for my themed list, but not the other one. Here's my themed list: Team Name: Pass me the Mike. Joker (Pick 1): Michael Waltrip Pick 2: Michael Douglas Pick 3: Michael Withacker Pick 4: Michael Caine Pick 5: Michael Gambon Pick 6: Michael J. Fox Pick 7: Michael Keaton Pick 8: Michael Shumacher Pick 9: Michael Dikakis Pick 10: Michael McDonald Pick 11: Mick Jagger Pick 12: (Michael) Duff McKagan Pick 13: Michael Andretti Pick 14: Michael Chiklis Pick 15: Michael Madsen Pick 16: Michael Jordan Pick 17: Michael Bolton Pick 18: Michael Bay Pick 19: Michael Ballack Pick 20: Mike Tyson Reserve Pick(s): Michael Myers Mike Oldfield mika brzezinski (only female here) I expect the confirmation, but here's the main team. Joker (Pick 1): Madeleine Albright Pick 2: Dries van Agt, former PM of the Netherlands Pick 3: Teake van der Meer, Frisian entertainer and sure to get a Dutch obit. Pick 4: Barry Gibb Pick 5: Nile Rodgers Pick 6: Nancy Reagan Pick 7: Bob Dole Pick 8: Jean “Toots” Tielemans Pick 9: Arie Ribbens, Dutch entertainer Pick 10: Fred Phelps Pick 11: Berry Gordy Pick 12: Smokey Robinson Pick 13: Hans Wiegel, Politician Pick 14: Anderson Cooper Pick 15: Bob Smalhout Pick 16: Horace Cohen, Comedian Pick 17: Maureen O’Hara Pick 18: Kirk Douglas Pick 19: Peter Salis Pick 20: Piet romeijn, Dutch footbal international, First person to call a referee “Hondenlul” (dog’s dick) Reserve Pick(s): Stephen Hawking Jan Des Bouvrie, Dutch designer Michael Douglas Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RIP Wee Jum 1,559 Posted January 2, 2013 My two teams The Arab League (Arabs) Pick 1: Hamida al-Attas (JOKER) Pick 2: Mahmoud Abbas Pick 3: Abdullah bin Abdulaziz Al Saud Pick 4: Sheikh Al-Ahmad Al Jaber Al-Sabah Pick 5: Mohammed Al-Fayed Pick 6: Tariq Aziz Pick 7: Farouk al-Sharaa Pick 8: Nouri al-Maliki Pick 9: Omar Abdel-Rahman Pick 10: Omar Al-Bashir Pick 11: Izzat Ibrahim al-Douri Pick 12: Yusuf Al-Qaradawi Pick 13: Ayman al-Zawahri Pick 14: Moqtada al-Sadr Pick 15: Abu Hamza al-Masri Pick 16: Maher Al-Assad Pick 17: Bashar Al-Assad Pick 18: Riad al-Asaad Pick 19: Mahmoud Ahmadinejad Pick 20: Fereydoon Abbasi-Davani Let's Get Ready To Rumble (People who were on hand @ Wretlemania 1) Pick 1: Muhammad Ali (JOKER) Pick 2: Pat Patterson Pick 3: Bob Orton, Jr. Pick 4: Paul Orndorff Pick 5: "Rowdy" Roddy Piper Pick 6: Jimmy Snuka Pick 7: Mr. T Pick 8: Hulk Hogan Pick 9: Bobby Heenan Pick 10: Barry Windham Pick 11: Mike Rotunda Pick 12: Iron Sheik Pick 13: Nikolai Volkoff Pick 14: Greg Valentine Pick 15: Johnny Valiant Pick 16: Brutus Beefcake Pick 17: Bruno Sammartino Pick 18: Tito Santana Pick 19: Jimmy Hart Pick 20: King Kong Bundy Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Magere Hein 1,400 Posted January 2, 2013 I expect the confirmation, but here's the main team. Pick 3: Teake van der Meer, Frisian entertainer and sure to get a Dutch obit. Pick 9: Arie Ribbens, Dutch entertainer Pick 13: Hans Wiegel, Politician Pick 15: Bob Smalhout Pick 20: Piet romeijn, Dutch footbal international, First person to call a referee “Hondenlul” (dog’s dick) Several brave picks there. 3, 9, 15 and 20 are not very likely to get UK obits. 13 will, but seems quite healthy. regards, Hein Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Whitehouse 872 Posted January 2, 2013 A bit unfair since there are numerous Brits I've never heard off. But okay, the rules.... (I could get lucky and get some unique picks.) I Recieved confirmiation on the lists. Thanks. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Death Impends 7,977 Posted January 2, 2013 I got the conformation for my theme team, if receiving the DDP Digest is tantamount to a confirmation then I also have for my main. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SchindlerHaughton 1 Posted January 3, 2013 Mine is as follows: Team Name: Melon Smashers & Melon Heads 1. Clive James (joker) 2. Margaret Thatcher 3. Jerry Lewis 4. Gallagher 5. Dick Cheney 6. Zsa Zsa Gabor 7. Billy Graham 8. Bob Dole 9. Michael Winner 10. Mary Tyler Moore 11. Muhammad Al 12. Hugo Chavez 13. Prince Philip 14. George H.W. Bush 15. Stan Lee 16. John Derbyshire 17. Bob Barker 18. Ray Price 19. Van Cliburn 20. Bonnie Franklin Reserve Picks: Courtney Love, Lindsay Lohan, Ethan Zohn Gallagher might not get a UK obit, but is an otherwise promising pick. He's my unique pick (hopefully). Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Eesti 151 Posted January 3, 2013 I am wondering, why teams don't get points if a person dies in 2012 and gets obit 2013. I understand that in some point you have to draw a line, because otherwise the results wouldn't be final. Neverthe less it is sad to see people lose points. Wouldn't it be better, if the person gets points if the obit comes within the first week of new year? It is obvious, that you don't get points in 2013 if a person dies in 2012, but still - the obit question. What do others think? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bert Trautmann 58 Posted January 3, 2013 I am wondering, why teams don't get points if a person dies in 2012 and gets obit 2013. I understand that in some point you have to draw a line, because otherwise the results wouldn't be final. Neverthe less it is sad to see people lose points. Wouldn't it be better, if the person gets points if the obit comes within the first week of new year? It is obvious, that you don't get points in 2013 if a person dies in 2012, but still - the obit question. What do others think? I think if someone doesn't die in 2013, then they shouldn't count in 2013. It's unlucky in cases which happen on the 31st but any other cut-off point would be arbitrary. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Toast 16,141 Posted January 3, 2013 I think it would be fair to allow points* for a late December death if the qualifying obit came on 1 January. This would not cause an undue delay to the final results. * just to clarify: points to count for the year ending, not the year just starting. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Windsor 2,233 Posted January 3, 2013 My theme team for 2013. (All have been appointed to the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire) 1. Rev Billy Graham, KBE (Joker). 2. Sir Nicholas Winton, MBE. 3. Liz Smith, MBE. 4. Dora Bryan, OBE. 5. Steven Hawking, CBE. 6. Peter Sallis, OBE. 7. Liz Dawn, MBE. 8. Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh, GBE and Grand Master. 9. Anna Wing, MBE. 10. Henry Kissenger, KBE. 11. Clive James, CBE. 12. Sir Morgan Morgan-Giles, OBE. 13. Stuart Hall, OBE. 14. Sir Robert G. Edwards, CBE. 15. Denis Healy, MBE. 16. Dennis Norden, CBE. 17. Sir Terry Pratchett, OBE. 18. The Lord Attenborough, CBE. 19. Sir Christopher Lee, CBE. 20. Leslie Phillips, CBE. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Going Underground 74 Posted January 3, 2013 I think it would be fair to allow points* for a late December death if the qualifying obit came on 1 January. This would not cause an undue delay to the final results. * just to clarify: points to count for the year ending, not the year just starting. I agree. If one of your current picks dies on New Years Eve it is unlikely any death announcement will be until the next year. I think the previous years final points count should not be officially announced until at least 3rd/4th Jan. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bert Trautmann 58 Posted January 3, 2013 I think it would be fair to allow points* for a late December death if the qualifying obit came on 1 January. This would not cause an undue delay to the final results. * just to clarify: points to count for the year ending, not the year just starting. I agree. If one of your current picks dies on New Years Eve it is unlikely any death announcement will be until the next year. I think the previous years final points count should not be officially announced until at least 3rd/4th Jan. But then who or what dictates whether it should be on the 3rd or the 4th or the 5th? Any cut-off point other than the turn of the year would be completely arbitrary...you'd just be moving the problem a few days forward if someone ended up getting the obituary on the 6th for example Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Toast 16,141 Posted January 3, 2013 I think it would be fair to allow points* for a late December death if the qualifying obit came on 1 January. This would not cause an undue delay to the final results. * just to clarify: points to count for the year ending, not the year just starting. I agree. If one of your current picks dies on New Years Eve it is unlikely any death announcement will be until the next year. I think the previous years final points count should not be officially announced until at least 3rd/4th Jan. But then who or what dictates whether it should be on the 3rd or the 4th or the 5th? Any cut-off point other than the turn of the year would be completely arbitrary...you'd just be moving the problem a few days forward if someone ended up getting the obituary on the 6th for example No, sorry, Bert - I don't agree. As things stand, there is virtually no chance of scoring points from a perfectly legitimate pick if said pick expires on 31 December. This surely is not fair. I think there's a case for giving a day's grace - possibly two, but I wouldn't extend it further than that as a line must be drawn, as you say. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bert Trautmann 58 Posted January 3, 2013 I think it would be fair to allow points* for a late December death if the qualifying obit came on 1 January. This would not cause an undue delay to the final results. * just to clarify: points to count for the year ending, not the year just starting. I agree. If one of your current picks dies on New Years Eve it is unlikely any death announcement will be until the next year. I think the previous years final points count should not be officially announced until at least 3rd/4th Jan. But then who or what dictates whether it should be on the 3rd or the 4th or the 5th? Any cut-off point other than the turn of the year would be completely arbitrary...you'd just be moving the problem a few days forward if someone ended up getting the obituary on the 6th for example No, sorry, Bert - I don't agree. As things stand, there is virtually no chance of scoring points from a perfectly legitimate pick if said pick expires on 31 December. This surely is not fair. I think there's a case for giving a day's grace - possibly two, but I wouldn't extend it further than that as a line must be drawn, as you say. I suppose you're right, deaths are usually only reported the following day...I wouldn't have a problem with a day's grace but I do worry that people would then argue for the line to be pushed further and further out. The only reason I'd want the deadline to remain as it is would be to prevent arguments about the point at which a pick does or does not count. Failing to score points on a pick who died on the 31st may have to be an unlucky, unfair but necessary sacrifice in that scenario. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
time 8,611 Posted January 3, 2013 I am wondering, why teams don't get points if a person dies in 2012 and gets obit 2013. I understand that in some point you have to draw a line, because otherwise the results wouldn't be final. Neverthe less it is sad to see people lose points. Wouldn't it be better, if the person gets points if the obit comes within the first week of new year? It is obvious, that you don't get points in 2013 if a person dies in 2012, but still - the obit question. What do others think? One of my picks for 2011 (Ronald Wolfe) died 18th December but no obit was forthcoming until January Did I feel aggrieved at missing out on the points? Not that much, and I soon got over any disappointment when the 2012 competition got under way. I understood the rules when I entered; it is when all's said and done, a bit of fun. As an academic exercise, maybe someone could have a look at the last couple of years or so and see if allowing early-next-year obits would have made any difference to the final result. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Toast 16,141 Posted January 3, 2013 Yes, but at least you had a fair chance of an obit arriving. No chance of that with NYE stiffs. (Well, unless it's some sort of spectacular accident like a survivorless plane crash in which celeb is known to be involved) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
themaninblack 2,112 Posted January 3, 2013 I am wondering, why teams don't get points if a person dies in 2012 and gets obit 2013. I understand that in some point you have to draw a line, because otherwise the results wouldn't be final. Neverthe less it is sad to see people lose points. Wouldn't it be better, if the person gets points if the obit comes within the first week of new year? It is obvious, that you don't get points in 2013 if a person dies in 2012, but still - the obit question. What do others think? One of my picks for 2011 (Ronald Wolfe) died 18th December but no obit was forthcoming until January Did I feel aggrieved at missing out on the points? Not that much, and I soon got over any disappointment when the 2012 competition got under way. I understood the rules when I entered; it is when all's said and done, a bit of fun. As an academic exercise, maybe someone could have a look at the last couple of years or so and see if allowing early-next-year obits would have made any difference to the final result. Er...but it did win points! Unless of course you mean Ronald SEARLE! This has happened already this year, with Daphne Oxenford dying on 21st December but the obit only coming to light today. Of course I'll make an exception if the legit obit is published before 23:59 31st December but I'm only made aware of it after January 1st... Thing is, there has to be a cut off point. During the year, you often get the likes of the Independent printing obits months after the pick has died. In DDP, you are straight into the next year, no close season or nothing. I can't juggle around two years at the same time. If Father Time says it's 2013, then it's 2013 and on we go... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
time 8,611 Posted January 3, 2013 Yes, but at least you had a fair chance of an obit arriving. No chance of that with NYE stiffs. (Well, unless it's some sort of spectacular accident like a survivorless plane crash in which celeb is known to be involved) I suspect that may depend on who it is, and what time of day it happened. An announcement on the BBC (or other qualifying news-source) website would suffice, and if, say, Maggie dropped, or HM or Phil went, there's a pretty good chance one would be up more or less straight away if it were Ronald Coase or Lindsay Lohan, we might have to wait a bit longer. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
time 8,611 Posted January 3, 2013 Er...but it did win points! Unless of course you mean Ronald SEARLE! I probably do. Still, you get the gist of it. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Windsor 2,233 Posted January 3, 2013 I suppose it wouldn't be a problem if we all chose ACTUAL celebrities... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Going Underground 74 Posted January 3, 2013 I think it would be fair to allow points* for a late December death if the qualifying obit came on 1 January. This would not cause an undue delay to the final results. * just to clarify: points to count for the year ending, not the year just starting. I agree. If one of your current picks dies on New Years Eve it is unlikely any death announcement will be until the next year. I think the previous years final points count should not be officially announced until at least 3rd/4th Jan. But then who or what dictates whether it should be on the 3rd or the 4th or the 5th? Any cut-off point other than the turn of the year would be completely arbitrary...you'd just be moving the problem a few days forward if someone ended up getting the obituary on the 6th for example Yes understood Bert and agree but the way it is leaves the competition open for someone to have a valid pick in a current year and it not get counted and may cost them a vital leader-board place. May as well say the 31st December doesn't count. Ok, maybe have until at least 23:59 on 1st Jan. That gives exactly 1 day for a new years eve hit to get an obit/mention and score points for the team. Surely a NYE hit must be given at least 24 hrs? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Going Underground 74 Posted January 3, 2013 sorry guys didn't see the subsequent discussion after Berts post before posting my reply. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Toast 16,141 Posted January 3, 2013 Yes, but at least you had a fair chance of an obit arriving. No chance of that with NYE stiffs. (Well, unless it's some sort of spectacular accident like a survivorless plane crash in which celeb is known to be involved) I suspect that may depend on who it is, and what time of day it happened. An announcement on the BBC (or other qualifying news-source) website would suffice, and if, say, Maggie dropped, or HM or Phil went, there's a pretty good chance one would be up more or less straight away if it were Ronald Coase or Lindsay Lohan, we might have to wait a bit longer. There's usually at least a few hours between death and announcement, though. May as well say the 31st December doesn't count. Agree. I don't make the rules, and so it's not for me to say, but IF I did, I'd allow that extra 24 hours for obits. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Magere Hein 1,400 Posted January 3, 2013 There's usually at least a few hours between death and announcement, though. How inconsiderate. Can't they announce NYE deaths a few hours before the celebrity in question buys the farm? regards, Hein Share this post Link to post Share on other sites