drol 12,190 Posted January 11 This year I got Jayapataka Swami and Shmuel Kamenetsky rejected. In both cases I did not particularly understand why, but Kamenetsky shocks me a little more (Badaani was allowed last year). Also I got Frank Caprio rejected when I subbed him in. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Toast 16,249 Posted January 11 I think it's just ignorance of the candidate and a failure to check them out properly. He rejected the Duchess of Kent one year. I politely expressed surprise, pointing out that she was internationally familiar for presenting the ladies trophy at Wimbledon, and he backtracked, saying I could have her after all. I suppose he assumed she was just some obscure British aristo and didn't bother to look her up. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
msc 18,565 Posted January 11 I was shocked my entire team got in first time. I can only assume it's shite! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bibliogryphon 9,654 Posted January 11 16 hours ago, drunkasaskunk said: Am I missing something here? How can a "pick" be rejected? I don't play this particular game but I think keeping the picks to a certain degree of fame keeps the game more interesting for casual observers and also allows for a slight removal of the 'ambulance chaser' reputation that outsiders may label us with. Where there is ambiguity (or even delay) in the qualifying obituary can make it difficult for game runners to keep track of. In 20/20 I do not police picks but it is very much for the players to provide the evidence if their pick has peripheral fame credentials. I much prefer the Scavenger Hunt because the qualifying criteria determines the level of fame required although there were some issues with Olympic medal winning cyclists in the last game Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Banana 865 Posted January 11 Bibian Mentel was denied despite being a 3-time Paralympic champion. Jesus Candel was accepted despite being just some health/doctor influencer. I tend to just send in any names that may seem like they could pass the arbitrary line and just accept it when they don’t. I’ve asked about royalty before and they’ve said that unless they’re fairly prominent they won’t get accepted. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
drunkasaskunk 197 Posted January 11 15 minutes ago, Banana said: Bibian Mentel was denied despite being a 3-time Paralympic champion. And this is exactly why it should be the mainstream media that decides (by publishing the requisite mention of their death) rather than some bloke sitting in his y-fronts eating a box of coco pops without milk. (oops - I forgot I moved the mirror !!!!!) https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/disability-sport/60508601 https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/01/sports/bibian-mentel-dead.html https://www.nbcsports.com/olympics/news/bibian-mentel-paralympic-snowboarding Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Lafaucheuse 4,099 Posted January 11 Just now, drunkasaskunk said: And this is exactly why it should be the mainstream media that decides (by publishing the requisite mention of their death) rather than some bloke sitting in his y-fronts eating a box of coco pops without milk. (oops - I forgot I moved the mirror !!!!!) https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/disability-sport/60508601 https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/01/sports/bibian-mentel-dead.html https://www.nbcsports.com/olympics/news/bibian-mentel-paralympic-snowboarding actually, I'm glad it's not solely based on qo since it allows non-UK picks to be taken. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Joey Russ 7,282 Posted January 11 Obviously I don’t play anymore, but one of my biggest shock moments was is the lead up in the 2018 pool where I decided to throw on Fu Da-ren as a replacement pick because I was curious. And was completely stunned when he was an acceptable pick. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gcreptile 11,105 Posted January 15 On 01/01/2024 at 18:38, Captain Hemlock said: Looks like this pool finished with exactly 200 hits. Congrats to @gcreptile who appears to be the champion. Well... I accept, lol I think it's over now, scores updated for Johnny Ruffo's bonus. Now, more recently, I think my pick Glen Cochrane managed the rare feat of not getting a QO in spite of being accepted. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
drol 12,190 Posted January 15 5 minutes ago, gcreptile said: Well... I accept, lol I think it's over now, scores updated for Johnny Ruffo's bonus. Now, more recently, I think my pick Glen Cochrane managed the rare feat of not getting a QO in spite of being accepted. I picked Munawwar Rana and he got the same obits as Rashid Khan, so I'm gonna complain a lot if he does not score. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gcreptile 11,105 Posted January 15 1 minute ago, drol said: I picked Munawwar Rana and he got the same obits as Rashid Khan, so I'm gonna complain a lot if he does not score. You were unlucky not to have a daily double with all these quick hits. Well done for picking these quick goners. I think one should go for those low-scoring but soon-to-be-on-their-way-out picks if a daily double is in reach. But Rana should definitely have obited by now. So I assume they were not working on 2024 these past two days, so maybe Cochrane is still to be counted with the nhl.com obit which "should" be respected enough. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
drol 12,190 Posted January 15 1 minute ago, gcreptile said: You were unlucky not to have a daily double with all these quick hits. Well done for picking these quick goners. I think one should go for those low-scoring but soon-to-be-on-their-way-out picks if a daily double is in reach. But Rana should definitely have obited by now. So I assume they were not working on 2024 these past two days, so maybe Cochrane is still to be counted with the nhl.com obit which "should" be respected enough. I'm worried because Shih Ming-teh was already added to strikeouts and he died today. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
drol 12,190 Posted January 15 I checked again and unexplicably forgot Munawwar Rana. Faulty brain. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gcreptile 11,105 Posted January 15 Yeah, he was in the running for almost every month of my last year's DeathList Cup game, but I never added him to my AltObits draft. Stupid. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
alt obits guy 3,386 Posted June 11 After a relatively quiet year, maybe things are picking up. Simon Cowell June 9th, now Françoise Hardy June 11th. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Captain Hemlock 755 Posted December 15 All my picks for 2025 were approved. I must be doing this wrong. Lol Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gcreptile 11,105 Posted December 17 On 01/01/2023 at 11:18, gcreptile said: Here are my rejects.... more than I expected... I just couldn't get them to accept Tim Lobinger. Some were doomed from the start though... Tim Lobinger Biagio Conte Jan Bloukaas Elin Kjos Joe Doering Natalie Fornassier Jango Edwards Chris Snow Naonobu Fujii Elena Huelva Haris Ibrahim Rocket Norton EC Stilson Mike Sertich Jean-Luc Brouillon Jan Bloukaas, young south african singer, dead after a cancer fight at 25: https://www.news24.com/life/arts-and-entertainment/celebrities/his-music-lives-on-beloved-afrikaans-star-jan-bloukaas-dies-at-25-after-courageous-cancer-battle-20241204 Edit: Guess I missed that one for two weeks. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
drol 12,190 Posted Sunday at 18:04 I usually struggle to find 40 names for this pool. But this year sucked so much I am spoilt for choice and will be forced to leave out obvious picks. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gcreptile 11,105 Posted Sunday at 22:19 I think you'll surely be in the running for the win eventually, or even next time. You'd be winning with 30+ nonagenarian hits, and a couple daily doubles or so... I might shift my attention away from this pool after next year. The focus on this one seems to have been detrimental to my success in other pools, or, the other pool. When the year 2024 came up, I was thinking that my team could not be beaten. But then a german musician (Torsun Teichgräber) died on Dec 30th. And then my unique pick Glen Cochrane didn't receive an obit. I thought that I could probably lose one name, but with two, it would be extremely close. And indeed, we now have this nerve-wrecking finish. One player hit the jackpot with picking Liam Payne. My team for 2025 is sort of ready, but I don't know, something isn't right. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
MariNisia 4,246 Posted Sunday at 23:40 Interesting and useful thoughts, @gcreptile. I definitely recommend this entertaining game, but this pool wouldn't be the same without you. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Old Crem 3,654 Posted Monday at 10:30 I always enter this but it takes me so long to put the names in Alphabetical order. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
drol 12,190 Posted Monday at 10:39 9 minutes ago, The Old Crem said: I always enter this but it takes me so long to put the names in Alphabetical order. Word does it authomatically. EDIT: or ask ChatGPT. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
livingbygrace 434 Posted Monday at 18:36 I have never entered this pool before. My one question would be can someone tell me why we give our names to the pool? Any other pool I know we just give our user name. Just curious before I decide if I will enter this year Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Toast 16,249 Posted Monday at 20:39 2 hours ago, livingbygrace said: I have never entered this pool before. My one question would be can someone tell me why we give our names to the pool? Any other pool I know we just give our user name. Just curious before I decide if I will enter this year You can make up a name. I do. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
livingbygrace 434 Posted Monday at 20:42 1 minute ago, Toast said: You can make up a name. I do. Thanks Toast.. It just threw me a bit not understanding why Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
