If you go back to your wife you do not keep a framed photo of your mistress.
Aye, but...unlike the other hired hands Wilson was brought in to write as well as perform, wasn't he. It might have got slated as a formless puddle of keyboard-noodling shite, but those are Wilson's lyrics on Calling All Stations, right?
I think he was brought in to try and make it look like the Genesis dynamic still existed. It was probably more a case of him being allowed to contribute to the writing rather than expected to.
It should probably be put down to a failed experiment.
It is still on my iPod though.
Wilson was hired late in the writing process so he didn't contribute much to the album - Banks and Rutherford have to take full blame for it, I am afraid. Having heard some of Wilson's solo stuff, it could have actually been worse had he been involved...
I remember at the time it came out, many fans were expecting Calling All Stations to be somewhat like And Then There Were Three, since both albums were basically just Rutherford-Banks co-writes and, in the sense that both are dreadful, so they are. (Okay, to be fair, I rather like Side 2 of And Then There Were Three but I think Side 1 possibly surpasses Calling All Stations for sheer awfulness.... )
I quite like individual tracks on ATTWT Burning Rope in particular Snowbound, Scenes from a Nights Dream, Say its Alright Joe, The Lady Lies and sometimes when I am in the mood Ballad of Big. However I tend not to listen to it as an album.