Kill or Save: UK No. 1-hits of the 70s

[Book 3,552]

32 minutes ago, TQR said:

The slightly annoying thing IMO with double A-sides in this game is that I Don’t Want To Talk About It is marvellous and worthy of the grand final, whereas The First Cut Is The Deepest is just 4 minutes of meh.

It would be unfair to everyone else if the two songs were rated separately. Since Rod Stewart only had one No.1 hit, albeit with a double A-side, it can only be counted as one song. How many songs did Demis Roussous' Phenomenon EP have? Just imagine if the songs were all listed separately...

[TQR 14,385]

5 minutes ago, Book said:

It would be unfair to everyone else if the two songs were rated separately. Since Rod Stewart only had one No.1 hit, albeit with a double A-side, it can only be counted as one song. How many songs did Demis Roussous' Phenomenon EP have? Just imagine if the songs were all listed separately...

I’m not saying they should be, I’m just saying it’s a personal gripe of mine and the reason for me not being prepared to give it any points. If anything it makes the scoring more interesting as people weigh up whether it’s worth propping up one crap song to save a great one.

[Toast 16,131]

It's a bit meaningless really.  All the other singles had two sides, the only difference is that in the case of a "double A side" both songs are named. 

The B side of Maggie May was Reason To Believe, which I greatly prefer.

 

[ThePrematureBurial 224]

My selections for Nov. 3:

 

67 Rod Stewart – I don't want to talk about it / The first cut is the deepest -6

68 Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie 

63 Donna Summer - I Feel Love

54 ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you 

42 ABBA - The Name of the Game 

40 ABBA - Fernando

31 ABBA - Mamma Mia

30.The Four Seasons – December 1963 (Oh, what a night)

26 Hot Chocolate – So you win again  

20 Elton John & Kiki Dee- Don`t go breaking my heart  +4

15 ABBA - Dancing Queen

0  Tina Charles – I love to love (But my baby loves to dance)  

 

 

[time 8,595]

26 minutes ago, ThePrematureBurial said:

My selections for Nov. 3:

 

67 Rod Stewart – I don't want to talk about it / The first cut is the deepest -6

68 Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie 

63 Donna Summer - I Feel Love

54 ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you 

42 ABBA - The Name of the Game 

40 ABBA - Fernando

31 ABBA - Mamma Mia

30.The Four Seasons – December 1963 (Oh, what a night)

26 Hot Chocolate – So you win again  

20 Elton John & Kiki Dee- Don`t go breaking my heart  +4

15 ABBA - Dancing Queen

0  Tina Charles – I love to love (But my baby loves to dance)  

 

Just signed in to give Elton a helping hand. 

I'd like to remind those who voted him down, that he survived many younger singers, who were ahead of him in the charts. 

I hope that this trend will continue.  

pssssst Its December.

[ThePrematureBurial 224]

23 hours ago, time said:

pssssst Its December.

 

 

[TQR 14,385]

18 minutes ago, ThePrematureBurial said:

 

No problem. I would be also satisfied, if he survives your favorite singers in January, February or in the year 2032. 

Just a small question here, what the fuck are you on about?

[En Passant 3,741]

3 minutes ago, TQR said:

Just a small question here, what the fuck are you on?

 

FTFY

 

53 minutes ago, ThePrematureBurial said:

I'd like to remind those who voted him down, that he survived many younger singers, who were ahead of him in the charts.

 

What in the name of all that is holy does that have to do with how good a song is?

We've already had one bout of a person voting for versions that aren't even listed - now this?

[ThePrematureBurial 224]

22 hours ago, TQR said:

Just a small question here, what the fuck are you on about?

 

 

 

[ThePrematureBurial 224]

22 hours ago, En Passant said:

 

FTFY

 

 

What in the name of all that is holy does that have to do with how good a song is?

We've already had one bout of a person voting for versions that aren't even listed - now this?

 

 

[msc 18,438]

As a fan of many Elton John songs, I am completely lost here.

[TQR 14,385]

15 minutes ago, ThePrematureBurial said:

 

Making jokes about dead VIPs on Deathlist is now a no-go?

 

Btw: Didn't you post in the Kanye West thread that mental illness is no excuse for Nazi views? 

 

I agree whole-heartedly, but at the same time people in this thread here suck up to David Bowie, whose mother was a a follower of Oswald Mosley, who collected Nazi memorabilia (confiscated in 1976 by the Russians) and who said that Britain was ready for a new Hitler. 

 

And nobody who reads my post should forget, that Bowie's groupie Lori Maddox was fourteen when he asked her to sleep with him, and fifteen when she did. 

 

Prince Andrew's Virginia was seventeen.
 

If anything you have made it a lot less clear as to what the fuck you’re on about, but as En Passant nodded to, a bit clearer as to what the fuck you’re on.

 

There we all are, merrily getting on with the game and having some chat about music, and all of a sudden you come in, say something about loads of people dying before Elton John (who I’m a huge fan of btw), then you bring up Nazis and noncery. Do you understand why one might be forgiven for thinking you’re off your fucking trolley?

[Toast 16,131]

35 minutes ago, ThePrematureBurial said:

And nobody who reads my post should forget, that Bowie's groupie Lori Maddox was fourteen when he asked her to sleep with him, and fifteen when she did.

 

Half the girls in my class at school were shagging like rabbits at 14 and 15.    It's normal, always has been, always will be.

[ThePrematureBurial 224]

22 hours ago, msc said:

As a fan of many Elton John songs, I am completely lost here.

 

 

[Toast 16,131]

8 minutes ago, ThePrematureBurial said:

 

I made a harmless joke about Elton surviving younger celebrities, and some deathlisters - who are probably posting right now on the Pele -thread, salivating for his death - got very angry and accused me on being on drugs or whatever.

 

Since I stumbled over TQR's posting on the Kanye- thread a while ago, I reminded him of the fact, that David Bowie, who had supremacist views, has many fans on this thread. 

 

What is there to misunderstand? I'm not here to spoil the fun for others.

 

 

Well, I didn't understand that you were on about dead people.  When you said EJ had survived "younger singers" I thought you were on topic and referring to survival in the current competition.

I've no idea why you wanted to bring dead celebrities into it. And what joke?  There wasn't anything funny about it, whichever way it was taken.

[ThePrematureBurial 224]

21 hours ago, Toast said:

 

Half the girls in my class at school were shagging like rabbits at 14 and 15.    It's normal, always has been, always will be.

 

 

21 hours ago, Toast said:

 

Well, I didn't understand that you were on about dead people.  When you said EJ had survived "younger singers" I thought you were on topic and referring to survival in the current competition.

I've no idea why you wanted to bring dead celebrities into it. And what joke?  There wasn't anything funny about it, whichever way it was taken.

 

 

 

[TQR 14,385]

[Toast 16,131]

 

[RoverAndOut 4,746]

After that brief descent into crazy, if I can bring us back to business...

 

68 Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie 

63 Donna Summer - I Feel Love

61 Rod Stewart – I don't want to talk about it / The first cut is the deepest -6

54 ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you 

44 ABBA - The Name of the Game +2

42 ABBA - Fernando +2

31 ABBA - Mamma Mia

30.The Four Seasons – December 1963 (Oh, what a night)

26 Hot Chocolate – So you win again  

20 Elton John & Kiki Dee- Don`t go breaking my heart

15 ABBA - Dancing Queen

 

Trying to put Rod back in his place. I don't mind the song, but I prefer others. I suspect there's enough love in here to keep him safe anyway, but I'll see if I can do something to get 3 ABBA songs through...

[TQR 14,385]

72 Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie +4

63 Donna Summer - I Feel Love

61 Rod Stewart – I don't want to talk about it / The first cut is the deepest

54 ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you 

44 ABBA - The Name of the Game

42 ABBA - Fernando

31 ABBA - Mamma Mia

26 Hot Chocolate – So you win again 

22 The Four Seasons – December 1963 (Oh, what a night) -6

20 Elton John & Kiki Dee- Don`t go breaking my heart

15 ABBA - Dancing Queen

[Bibliogryphon 9,571]

72 Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie 

63 Donna Summer - I Feel Love

61 Rod Stewart – I don't want to talk about it / The first cut is the deepest

54 ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you 

44 ABBA - The Name of the Game

42 ABBA - Fernando

33 ABBA - Mamma Mia +2

26 Hot Chocolate – So you win again 

22 Elton John & Kiki Dee- Don`t go breaking my heart +2

19 The Four Seasons – December 1963 (Oh, what a night) -3

12 ABBA - Dancing Queen -3

[Book 3,552]

72 Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie 

63 Donna Summer - I Feel Love

61 Rod Stewart – I don't want to talk about it / The first cut is the deepest

58 ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you  +4

44 ABBA - The Name of the Game

42 ABBA - Fernando

33 ABBA - Mamma Mia

22 Elton John & Kiki Dee- Don`t go breaking my heart

20 Hot Chocolate – So you win again   -6

19 The Four Seasons – December 1963 (Oh, what a night)

12 ABBA - Dancing Queen

 

 

If you read back a bit, this thread really has so much to offer...

 

[theoldlady 2,297]

Here are my selections for Sunday,  December 4th.

72 Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie 

63 Donna Summer - I Feel Love

61 Rod Stewart – I don't want to talk about it / The first cut is the deepest

58 ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you

46 ABBA - Fernando +4

44 ABBA - The Name of the Game

33 ABBA - Mamma Mia

19 The Four Seasons - December 1963 (Oh, what a night)

18 Elton John & Kiki Dee - Don`t go breaking my heart -4

18 Hot Chocolate – So you win again  -2 

12 ABBA - Dancing Queen

 

[ladyfiona 2,577]

72 Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie 

61 Rod Stewart – I don't want to talk about it / The first cut is the deepest

60 ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you +2

57 Donna Summer - I Feel Love -6

46 ABBA - Fernando

46 ABBA - The Name of the Game +2

33 ABBA - Mamma Mia

19 The Four Seasons - December 1963 (Oh, what a night)

18 Elton John & Kiki Dee - Don`t go breaking my heart

18 Hot Chocolate – So you win again 

12 ABBA - Dancing Queen 

[Clorox Bleachman 2,410]

You can't tell me any of these ABBA songs are better than I Feel Love.

 

72 Baccara – Yes Sir, I can boogie

61 Rod Stewart – I don't want to talk about it / The first cut is the deepest

61 Donna Summer - I Feel Love +4

60 ABBA – Knowing me, knowing you

46 ABBA - Fernando

46 ABBA - The Name of the Game

33 ABBA - Mamma Mia

19 The Four Seasons - December 1963 (Oh, what a night)

18 Elton John & Kiki Dee - Don`t go breaking my heart

18 Hot Chocolate – So you win again

6 ABBA - Dancing Queen -6