Jump to content
Bibliogryphon

Who Stays in 25 - Kill or Save Special

Recommended Posts

At this time of year people will be focused on trying to predict which way the committee will jump with regards to  retained names and this year with so few hits the choice will be even more difficult.

 

So I have thought why not bring some modicum of consensus to the debate for the committee to ignore using the tried and trusted Kill or Save methodology that has proven so popular 

 

I have listed below the current 45 survivors which we need to whittle down to 25 names

 

- Each person starts with 20 points.

- You can vote once a day. Since we all live in different parts of the world with all sorts of different timezones, please add a date at the top of your votes to avoid any type of confusion (e.g. 18/9/24, 18th of September, Wed 18 Sept, etc.). 

- Each day you can give 4 points and subtract 6 points to any nane on the board, you can split your points between as many names as you want.

-Placeholder posts are allowed, but if you don't edit your votes within 5 minutes, then the next person can go and do their votes.

-Consecutive votes are not allowed.

- New Rule for this game until the first person is eliminated you cannot give more than 50% of you score (+2/-3) to a single individual

- Make sure you copy and paste the most recent voter's scoreboard when you take your turn to score. For your own ease, ‘paste as plain text’ to get rid of the previous poster’s formatting. Then, delete their +/- scores, add yours, adjust the name's points total and make your scores bold

 

If you do eliminate a name please update the counter. Game is over when 20 names are eliminated 

 

 

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The list

 

• Jimmy Carter
• Dick van Dyke
• Pete Murray
• Alan Greenspan
• Pope Francis
• Cleo Laine 
• Sandy Gall
• Noam Chomsky
• Robert Wagner
• Mel Brooks
• Dennis Skinner
• Nigel Starmer-Smith
• James Whale
• Stanley Baxter
• Joanne Woodward
• Patricia Routledge
• Clint Eastwood
• Vanessa Redgrave
• Desmond Morris
• Gene Hackman
• Jean-Marie Le Pen
• Denis Law
• Hans Blix
• Julie Walters
• Tom Brokaw
• Linda Nolan
• Louis Farrakhan
• Norman Tebbit
• Willie Nelson
• Daniel Barenboim
• Esther Rantzen
• Roberta Flack
• Dick Cheney
• Prunella Scales
• Robert Duvall
• Josef Fritzl
• Brigitte Bardot
• Raul Castro
• Imelda Marcos
• Ted Turner
• Buzz Aldrin
• Sonny Rollins
• Sly Stone 
• Tom Baker
• Joe Bugner

 

0/20

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 minutes ago, Bibliogryphon said:

At this time of year people will be focused on trying to predict which way the committee will jump with regards to  retained names and this year with so few hits the choice will be even more difficult.

 

So I have thought why not bring some modicum of consensus to the debate for the committee to ignore using the tried and trusted Kill or Save methodology that has proven so popular 

 

I have listed below the current 45 survivors which we need to whittle down to 25 names

 

- Each person starts with 20 points.

- You can vote once a day. Since we all live in different parts of the world with all sorts of different timezones, please add a date at the top of your votes to avoid any type of confusion (e.g. 18/9/24, 18th of September, Wed 18 Sept, etc.). 

- Each day you can give 4 points and subtract 6 points to any song on the board, you can split your points between as many songs as you want.

-Placeholder posts are allowed, but if you don't edit your votes within 5 minutes, then the next person can go and do their votes.

-Consecutive votes are not allowed.

- New Rule for this game until the first person is eliminated you cannot give more than 50% of you score (+2/-3) to a single individual

- Make sure you copy and paste the most recent voter's scoreboard when you take your turn to score. For your own ease, ‘paste as plain text’ to get rid of the previous poster’s formatting. Then, delete their +/- scores, add yours, adjust the song’s points total and make your scores bold

 

 

You might want to adjust this to change it from songs to individuals ;)

  • Facepalm 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At least there won't be an argument about 90s EDM music.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Bibliogryphon I like this thread but I also still think we should have a thread "Who Should Go On The 2025 Deathlist?" 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Steve said:

@Bibliogryphon I like this thread but I also still think we should have a thread "Who Should Go On The 2025 Deathlist?" 

 

There is still the ideas and possibilities.  This only works because there is a finite number of options

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Bibliogryphon said:

 

There is still the ideas and possibilities.  This only works because there is a finite number of options

I get that but I see that thread as more broader which includes B-lister and minor name suggestions where "Who Should Go On The 2025 Deathlist?" thread is specific to A-lister names that should go on the official list imo. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Steve said:

@Bibliogryphon I like this thread but I also still think we should have a thread "Who Should Go On The 2025 Deathlist?" 

 

The "Who Should Be On The 20XX Deathlist?" thread usually opens in late November.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, polar duck said:

 

The "Who Should Be On The 20XX Deathlist?" thread usually opens in late November.

 

Then you get Crowdsourced DL and multiple "shadow DL" threads.  That's more than enough.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let's start Killing and Saving

 

21 Jimmy Carter +1

21 Norman Tebbit +1

21 Tom Baker +1

21 Joanne Woodward +1
20 Dick van Dyke
20 Pete Murray
20 Alan Greenspan
20 Pope Francis
20 Cleo Laine 
20 Sandy Gall 
20 Noam Chomsky
20 Robert Wagner
20 Mel Brooks
20 Dennis Skinner
20 Nigel Starmer-Smith
20 James Whale
20 Stanley Baxter
20 Patricia Routledge
20 Clint Eastwood
20 Vanessa Redgrave
20 Desmond Morris
20 Gene Hackman
20 Jean-Marie Le Pen
20Denis Law
20 Hans Blix
20 Tom Brokaw
20 Linda Nolan
20 Louis Farrakhan
20 Willie Nelson
20 Daniel Barenboim
20 Esther Rantzen
20 Roberta Flack
20 Dick Cheney
20Prunella Scales
20 Robert Duvall
20 Brigitte Bardot
20 Raul Castro
20 Imelda Marcos
20 Ted Turner
20 Buzz Aldrin
20 Sonny Rollins
20 Sly Stone 
18 Julie Walters -2
18 Joe Bugner -2

18 Josef Fritzl -2

 

0/20

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
45 minutes ago, Bibliogryphon said:

Let's start Killing and Saving

Nov. 9 2024

22 Jimmy Carter +1

21Norman Tebbit

21 Tom Baker 

21 Joanne Woodward 
21 Dick van Dyke +1
20 Pete Murray
21 Alan Greenspan +1
20 Pope Francis
20 Cleo Laine 
20 Sandy Gall 
20 Noam Chomsky
20 Robert Wagner
20 Mel Brooks
20 Dennis Skinner
20 Nigel Starmer-Smith
20 James Whale
20 Stanley Baxter
21 Patricia Routledge +1
20 Clint Eastwood
20 Vanessa Redgrave
20 Desmond Morris
20 Gene Hackman
20 Jean-Marie Le Pen
20Denis Law
20 Hans Blix
20 Tom Brokaw
20 Linda Nolan
20 Louis Farrakhan
20 Willie Nelson
20 Daniel Barenboim
20 Esther Rantzen
20 Roberta Flack
18 Dick Cheney -2
20Prunella Scales
20 Robert Duvall
20 Brigitte Bardot
20 Raul Castro
20 Imelda Marcos
20 Ted Turner
20 Buzz Aldrin
20 Sonny Rollins
20 Sly Stone 
18 Julie Walters 
16Joe Bugner -2

16 Josef Fritzl -2

 

0/25

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

November 9 2024

22 Jimmy Carter

22 Stanley Baxter +2

21 Norman Tebbit

21 Tom Baker 

21 Joanne Woodward 
21 Dick van Dyke

21 Tom Brokaw +1

20 Pete Murray
21 Alan Greenspan
20 Pope Francis
20 Cleo Laine 
20 Sandy Gall 
20 Noam Chomsky
20 Robert Wagner
20 Mel Brooks
20 Dennis Skinner
20 James Whale
21 Patricia Routledge
20 Clint Eastwood
20 Vanessa Redgrave
20 Desmond Morris
20 Gene Hackman
20 Jean-Marie Le Pen
20 Denis Law
20 Hans Blix
20 Linda Nolan
20 Louis Farrakhan
20 Willie Nelson
20 Daniel Barenboim
20 Esther Rantzen
20 Roberta Flack
20 Raul Castro
20 Imelda Marcos
20 Ted Turner
20 Sonny Rollins
20 Sly Stone 

19 Nigel Starmer-Smith -1
19 Dick Cheney +1

19 Prunella Scales -1
19 Robert Duvall -1

18 Brigitte Bardot -2

18 Buzz Aldrin -2

18 Julie Walters 
16 Joe Bugner

16 Josef Fritzl

 

0/20

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The eliminator score should be 0/20 not 0/25

 

Please correct

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

9 November 2024 23:20

 

22 Jimmy Carter

22 Stanley Baxter

21 Norman Tebbit

21 Tom Baker 

21 Joanne Woodward 
21 Dick van Dyke

21 Tom Brokaw

20 Pete Murray
21 Alan Greenspan
21 Pope Francis +1
20 Cleo Laine 
20 Sandy Gall 
20 Noam Chomsky
19 Robert Wagner -1
20 Mel Brooks
20 Dennis Skinner
20 James Whale
23 Patricia Routledge +2
20 Clint Eastwood
19 Vanessa Redgrave -1
19 Desmond Morris -1
20 Gene Hackman
20 Jean-Marie Le Pen
20 Denis Law
20 Hans Blix
20 Linda Nolan
19 Louis Farrakhan -1
20 Willie Nelson
20 Daniel Barenboim
20 Esther Rantzen
20 Roberta Flack
21 Raul Castro +1
20 Imelda Marcos
20 Ted Turner
20 Sonny Rollins
20 Sly Stone 

18 Nigel Starmer-Smith -1
19 Dick Cheney

18 Prunella Scales -1
19 Robert Duvall

18 Brigitte Bardot

18 Buzz Aldrin

18 Julie Walters 
16 Joe Bugner

16 Josef Fritzl

 

0/20

Edited by Grimgrass
Corrected the eliminator score

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

9 November 2024 

 

23 Patricia Routledge 

22 Jimmy Carter

22 Stanley Baxter

21 Norman Tebbit

21 Tom Baker 

21 Raul Castro 

21 Joanne Woodward 
21 Dick van Dyke

21 Alan Greenspan
21 Pope Francis 

21 Imelda Marcos + 1

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen + 1

20 Pete Murray
20 Cleo Laine 
20 Sandy Gall 
20 Noam Chomsky 
20 Mel Brooks
20 Dennis Skinner
20 James Whale
20 Clint Eastwood 
20 Gene Hackman
20 Denis Law
20 Linda Nolan

20 Brigitte Bardot + 2
20 Willie Nelson
20 Daniel Barenboim -
20 Esther Rantzen
20 Roberta Flack
20 Ted Turner
20 Sonny Rollins
20 Sly Stone 

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Tom Brokaw - 2

19 Vanessa Redgrave 
19 Desmond Morris 

19 Hans Blix -1 

19 Robert Wagner 

19 Robert Duvall

18 Prunella Scales 

18 Nigel Starmer-Smith 

18 Buzz Aldrin

18 Julie Walters 
16 Joe Bugner

16 Josef Fritzl

16 Dick Cheney - 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

09.11.2024

 

23 Patricia Routledge 

22 Jimmy Carter

22 Stanley Baxter

22 Norman Tebbit +1

22 Raul Castro +1

21 Tom Baker 

21 Joanne Woodward 
21 Dick van Dyke

21 Alan Greenspan
21 Pope Francis 

21 Imelda Marcos

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen

21 Dennis Skinner +1

20 Pete Murray
20 Cleo Laine 
20 Sandy Gall 
20 Noam Chomsky 
20 Mel Brooks
20 James Whale
20 Clint Eastwood 
20 Gene Hackman
20 Denis Law
20 Linda Nolan

20 Brigitte Bardot
20 Willie Nelson
20 Daniel Barenboim -
20 Esther Rantzen
20 Roberta Flack
20 Ted Turner
20 Sonny Rollins
20 Sly Stone 

20 Tom Brokaw +1

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Vanessa Redgrave 
19 Desmond Morris 

19 Hans Blix

19 Robert Duvall

18 Prunella Scales 

18 Nigel Starmer-Smith 

18 Buzz Aldrin

16 Robert Wagner -3

16 Joe Bugner

16 Josef Fritzl

16 Dick Cheney

15 Julie Walters -3

 

Eliminator Score: 0/20.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

09.11.2024

 

23 Patricia Routledge 

22 Linda Nolan  +2

22 Esther Rantzen  +2

22 Stanley Baxter  

22 Norman Tebbit 

22 Raul Castro 

22 Jimmy Carter

21 Tom Baker 

21 Joanne Woodward 
21 Dick van Dyke

21 Alan Greenspan
21 Pope Francis 

21 Imelda Marcos

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen

21 Dennis Skinner 

20 Pete Murray
20 Cleo Laine 
20 Sandy Gall 
20 Noam Chomsky 
20 Mel Brooks
20 James Whale
20 Clint Eastwood 
20 Gene Hackman
20 Denis Law

20 Brigitte Bardot
20 Willie Nelson
20 Daniel Barenboim 
20 Roberta Flack
20 Ted Turner
20 Sonny Rollins
20 Sly Stone 

20 Tom Brokaw 

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Vanessa Redgrave 
19 Desmond Morris 

19 Hans Blix

19 Robert Duvall

18 Prunella Scales 

18 Nigel Starmer-Smith 

18 Buzz Aldrin

16 Joe Bugner

16 Josef Fritzl

15 Julie Walters 

13 Dick Cheney  -3

13 Robert Wagner -3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

09.11.2024

 

23 Patricia Routledge 

22 Linda Nolan 

22 Esther Rantzen 

22 Stanley Baxter  

22 Norman Tebbit 

22 Raul Castro 

22 Jimmy Carter

22 Noam Chomsky +2

21 Joanne Woodward 
21 Dick van Dyke

21 Alan Greenspan
21 Pope Francis 

21 Imelda Marcos

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen

21 Dennis Skinner 

21 Gene Hackman +1

21 Cleo Laine +1

20 Pete Murray
20 Sandy Gall 
20 Mel Brooks
20 James Whale
20 Clint Eastwood 
20 Denis Law

20 Brigitte Bardot
20 Willie Nelson
20 Daniel Barenboim 
20 Roberta Flack
20 Ted Turner
20 Sonny Rollins
20 Sly Stone 

20 Tom Brokaw 

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Vanessa Redgrave 
19 Desmond Morris 

19 Hans Blix

19 Tom Baker -2

18 Prunella Scales 

18 Nigel Starmer-Smith 

18 Buzz Aldrin

17 Robert Duvall -2

16 Joe Bugner

16 Josef Fritzl

13 Julie Walters -2

13 Dick Cheney 

13 Robert Wagner

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

11/9/2024

 

23 Patricia Routledge 

22 Alan Greenspan +1

22 Roberta Flack +2

22 Linda Nolan 

22 Esther Rantzen 

22 Stanley Baxter 

22 Norman Tebbit 

22 Raul Castro 

22 Jimmy Carter

22 Noam Chomsky

21 Sonny Rollins +1

21 Joanne Woodward 

21 Dick van Dyke

21 Pope Francis 

21 Imelda Marcos

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen

21 Dennis Skinner 

21 Gene Hackman

21 Cleo Laine

20 Pete Murray

20 Sandy Gall 

20 Mel Brooks

20 James Whale

20 Clint Eastwood 

20 Denis Law

20 Brigitte Bardot

20 Daniel Barenboim 

20 Ted Turner

20 Sly Stone 

20 Tom Brokaw 

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Vanessa Redgrave 

19 Desmond Morris 

19 Tom Baker

18 Prunella Scales 

18 Nigel Starmer-Smith 

18 Buzz Aldrin

18 Hans Blix -1

18 Willie Nelson -2

17 Robert Duvall

16 Joe Bugner

16 Josef Fritzl

13 Dick Cheney 

13 Robert Wagner

10 Julie Walters -3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

10.11.

 

24 Jimmy Carter +2

23 Patricia Routledge 

22 Linda Nolan 

22 Esther Rantzen 

22 Stanley Baxter 

22 Norman Tebbit 

22 Raul Castro 

22 Alan Greenspan

22 Noam Chomsky 

22 Roberta Flack

21 Joanne Woodward 

21 Pope Francis 

21 Imelda Marcos

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen

21 Dennis Skinner 

21 Gene Hackman 

21 Cleo Laine 

21 Sonny Rollins

21 Sly Stone +1

20 Dick van Dyke -1

20 Pete Murray

20 Sandy Gall 

20 Mel Brooks

20 James Whale

20 Clint Eastwood 

20 Denis Law

20 Brigitte Bardot

20 Daniel Barenboim 

20 Ted Turner

20 Tom Brokaw 

19 Hans Blix +1

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Vanessa Redgrave 

19 Desmond Morris 

19 Tom Baker 

18 Nigel Starmer-Smith 

18 Willie Nelson

18 Buzz Aldrin

17 Robert Duvall

16 Prunella Scales -2

16 Joe Bugner

16 Josef Fritzl

13 Dick Cheney 

13 Robert Wagner

7 Julie Walters -3

 

Eliminator score: 0/20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

11/09/2024

 

24 Jimmy Carter

23 Patricia Routledge

23 Noam Chomsky +1 

22 Linda Nolan 

22 Esther Rantzen 

22 Stanley Baxter 

22 Norman Tebbit 

22 Raul Castro 

22 Alan Greenspan

22 Roberta Flack

21 Joanne Woodward 

21 Imelda Marcos

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen

21 Dennis Skinner 

21 Gene Hackman 

21 Cleo Laine 

21 Sonny Rollins

21 Sly Stone

21 Ted Turner +1

20 Dick van Dyke

20 Pete Murray

20 Sandy Gall 

20 Mel Brooks

20 James Whale

20 Clint Eastwood 

20 Brigitte Bardot

20 Daniel Barenboim 

20 Tom Brokaw 

19 Denis Law -1

19 Pope Francis -2

19 Hans Blix

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Vanessa Redgrave 

19 Desmond Morris 

19 Tom Baker 

18 Nigel Starmer-Smith 

18 Willie Nelson

18 Buzz Aldrin

18 Josef Fritzl +2

17 Robert Duvall

16 Prunella Scales 

16 Joe Bugner

13 Dick Cheney 

12 Robert Wagner -1

5 Julie Walters -2

 

Eliminator score: 0/20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

11/09/2024

 

25 Jimmy Carter +1

23 Patricia Routledge

23 Noam Chomsky 

22 Linda Nolan 

22 Esther Rantzen 

22 Stanley Baxter 

22 Norman Tebbit 

22 Raul Castro 

22 Alan Greenspan

22 Roberta Flack

22 Joanne Woodward +1

21 Imelda Marcos

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen

21 Dennis Skinner 

21 Gene Hackman 

21 Cleo Laine 

21 Sonny Rollins

21 Sly Stone

23 Ted Turner +2

20 Dick van Dyke

20 Pete Murray

20 Sandy Gall 

20 Mel Brooks

20 James Whale

20 Clint Eastwood 

20 Brigitte Bardot

20 Daniel Barenboim 

20 Tom Brokaw 

19 Denis Law 

17 Pope Francis -2

19 Hans Blix

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Vanessa Redgrave 

19 Desmond Morris 

19 Tom Baker 

18 Nigel Starmer-Smith 

18 Willie Nelson

16 Buzz Aldrin -2

18 Josef Fritzl 

17 Robert Duvall

16 Prunella Scales 

16 Joe Bugner

13 Dick Cheney 

12 Robert Wagner 

3 Julie Walters -2

 

Eliminator score: 0/20

Edited by HDS
Timing

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

9th Nov 24

 

27 Jimmy Carter +2

24 Noam Chomsky +1

23 Patricia Routledge

22 Linda Nolan 

22 Esther Rantzen 

22 Stanley Baxter 

22 Norman Tebbit 

22 Raul Castro 

22 Alan Greenspan

22 Roberta Flack

22 Joanne Woodward 

21 Imelda Marcos

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen

21 Dennis Skinner 

21 Gene Hackman 

21 Cleo Laine 

21 Sonny Rollins

21 Sly Stone

23 Ted Turner 

20 Dick van Dyke

20 Pete Murray

20 Sandy Gall 

20 James Whale

20 Clint Eastwood 

20 Brigitte Bardot

20 Daniel Barenboim 

20 Tom Brokaw 

19 Denis Law 

18 Mel Brooks -2

17 Pope Francis 

19 Hans Blix

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Vanessa Redgrave 

19 Desmond Morris 

19 Tom Baker 

19 Nigel Starmer-Smith +1

18 Willie Nelson

16 Buzz Aldrin 

18 Josef Fritzl 

17 Robert Duvall

16 Prunella Scales 

16 Joe Bugner

13 Dick Cheney 

11 Robert Wagner -1

0 Julie Walters -3

 

Eliminator score: 1/20

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

9/11/24

 

27 Jimmy Carter 

26 Noam Chomsky +2

23 Esther Rantzen +1

23 Patricia Routledge

23 Ted Turner

22 Linda Nolan 

22 Stanley Baxter 

22 Norman Tebbit 

22 Raul Castro 

22 Alan Greenspan

22 Roberta Flack

22 Joanne Woodward 

21 Imelda Marcos

21 Jean-Marie Le Pen

21 Dennis Skinner 

21 Gene Hackman 

21 Cleo Laine 

21 Sonny Rollins

20 Dick van Dyke

20 Pete Murray

20 Sandy Gall 

20 James Whale

20 Clint Eastwood 

20 Brigitte Bardot

20 Daniel Barenboim 

20 Tom Brokaw 

20 Denis Law +1

18 Mel Brooks

19 Hans Blix

19 Louis Farrakhan 

19 Vanessa Redgrave 

19 Desmond Morris 

19 Tom Baker 

19 Nigel Starmer-Smith 

18 Willie Nelson

18 Josef Fritzl 

18 Sly Stone -3

17 Pope Francis 

17 Robert Duvall

16 Buzz Aldrin 

16 Prunella Scales 

16 Joe Bugner

11 Robert Wagner

10 Dick Cheney -3

 

Eliminator score: 1/20

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×

Important Information

Your use of this forum is subject to our Terms of Use