Kill or Save: UK No. 1-hits of the 70s

[Toast 16,140]

48 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

36 Blondie – Heart of glass

34 Bee Gees - Night Fever

34 Gary Numan - Cars  +2

31 Police – Message in a bottle

30 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric   +2

29 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

26 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

22 Blondie – Sunday Girl

21 ABBA – Take a chance on me

20 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

16 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall

11 Police – Walking on the moon

11 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes  -6

[wannamaker 1,407]

48 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

36 Blondie – Heart of glass

34 Bee Gees - Night Fever

34 Gary Numan - Cars 

31 Police – Message in a bottle

31 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick +2

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star +2 

24 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric -6

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

22 Blondie – Sunday Girl

21 ABBA – Take a chance on me

20 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

16 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall

11 Police – Walking on the moon

11 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes  

[CaptainChorizo 1,982]

50 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking +2

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

36 Blondie – Heart of glass

36 Bee Gees - Night Fever +2

34 Gary Numan - Cars 

31 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick

29 Police – Message in a bottle -2

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star

24 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

22 Blondie – Sunday Girl

21 ABBA – Take a chance on me

20 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

12 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall -4

11 Police – Walking on the moon

11 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes  

[Book 3,556]

54 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking +4

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

36 Blondie – Heart of glass

36 Bee Gees - Night Fever

34 Gary Numan - Cars 

31 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star

24 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

23 Police – Message in a bottle  -6

22 Blondie – Sunday Girl

21 ABBA – Take a chance on me

20 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

12 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall

11 Police – Walking on the moon

11 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes  

[theoldlady 2,301]

 

54 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking 

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Height

40 Bee Gees - Night Fever +4

36 Blondie – Heart of glass

34 Gary Numan - Cars 

31 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star

24 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

23 Police – Message in a bottle  

22 Blondie – Sunday Girl

21 ABBA – Take a chance on me

20 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

12 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall

11 Police – Walking on the moon

5 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes  -6

[Bibliogryphon 9,582]

54 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking 

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Height

38 Bee Gees - Night Fever -2

36 Blondie – Heart of glass

34 Gary Numan - Cars 

31 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star +2

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

25 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday +2

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 Police – Message in a bottle  

22 Blondie – Sunday Girl

22 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric -2

21 ABBA – Take a chance on me

20 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

12 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall

9 Police – Walking on the moon -2

5 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes 

[Clorox Bleachman 2,432]

54 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

38 Bee Gees - Night Fever

36 Blondie – Heart of glass

31 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 Gary Numan - Cars -6

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric +4

25 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 Police – Message in a bottle

22 Blondie – Sunday Girl

21 ABBA – Take a chance on me

20 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

12 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall

9 Police – Walking on the moon

5 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes

[Great Uncle Bulgaria 1,283]

 

51 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking -3

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

38 Bee Gees - Night Fever

36 Blondie – Heart of glass

31 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 Gary Numan - Cars 

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

25 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 Police – Message in a bottle

23 Blondie – Sunday Girl+1

22 ABBA – Take a chance on me +1

22 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap +2

9 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall -3

9 Police – Walking on the moon

5 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes

 

Bit mystified by the love for Althia and Donna. Like, say, pass the Dutchie it's a jolly enough little reggae number but hardly in the same class as some of the above. I remember their first outing on TOTP (UK chart show) back in the day, they looked like a couple of rabbits in the headlights and struggled to sing in time/tune.

 

[TQR 14,396]

I know Sting’s a wanker, but I’m surprised/slightly miffed at how low down the two The Police songs are. Message In A Bottle is easily top-5 in this list imo.

[justonecornetto 950]

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

47 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking -4

40 Blondie – Heart of glass +4

38 Bee Gees - Night Fever

31 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 Gary Numan - Cars 

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

25 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 Police – Message in a bottle

23 Blondie – Sunday Girl

22 ABBA – Take a chance on me 

22 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap 

9 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall 

9 Police – Walking on the moon

3 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes -2

[Grim Up North 3,726]

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

47 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

40 Blondie – Heart of glass

38 Bee Gees - Night Fever

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 Gary Numan - Cars 

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

26 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap +4

25 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick -6

25 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 Police – Message in a bottle

23 Blondie – Sunday Girl

22 ABBA – Take a chance on me 

9 Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall 

9 Police – Walking on the moon

3 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes

[Toast 16,140]

36 minutes ago, Great Uncle Bulgaria said:

Bit mystified by the love for Althia and Donna. Like, say, pass the Dutchie it's a jolly enough little reggae number but hardly in the same class as some of the above. I remember their first outing on TOTP (UK chart show) back in the day, they looked like a couple of rabbits in the headlights and struggled to sing in time/tune.

 

I remember it well!  We were all captivated by them, and thought they were adorable. 

As for the song, it never fails to make me smile, and wiggle my arse.  And join in with the little squeals.  Oooh! 

 

24 minutes ago, TQR said:

I know Sting’s a wanker, but I’m surprised/slightly miffed at how low down the two The Police songs are. Message In A Bottle is easily top-5 in this list imo.

 

Just so much good stuff here.  I'm similarly shocked when people vote down (I won't say which as someone will target it if I do).

There's really only a couple left that I'm not so keen on, and those are tolerable.

[msc 18,472]

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

47 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

42 Bee Gees - Night Fever +4

40 Blondie – Heart of glass

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 Gary Numan - Cars 

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

26 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap 

25 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick 

25 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 Police – Message in a bottle

23 Blondie – Sunday Girl

22 ABBA – Take a chance on me 

9 Police – Walking on the moon

3 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes

3 Pink Floyd - Another Brick in the Wall -6

 

Genuinely difficult to find one to give minus points to, tbh.

 

Also, Sting? Annoying sod, but he wrote many good songs.

[En Passant 3,741]

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

47 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

42 Bee Gees - Night Fever

40 Blondie – Heart of glass

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

28 Gary Numan - Cars 

27 Police – Message in a bottle +4

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

26 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap 

25 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick 

25 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

23 Blondie – Sunday Girl

22 ABBA – Take a chance on me 

21 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive -3

9 Police – Walking on the moon

3 Pink Floyd - Another Brick in the Wall

0 Art Garfunkel – Bright eyes -3

 

Well this won't come as a shock, I'm doing exactly what I said I would, and yes, I also believe other people are holding a grudge when their 'fave' got downvoted - however, since I've always cared more about getting rid of dross than what actually wins or stays in (as long as they're pretty decent tracks I'm actually fairly ambivalent about which actual ones) I could now be voting up those I'd rather they picked on, so it's +4 me -6 them. This double agency has nothing to do with my currently watching spooks on re-runs, nothing at all.

[TQR 14,396]

1 hour ago, Clorox Bleachman said:

28 Gary Numan - Cars -6

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric +4

This is a fascinating use of points given they’re not exactly chalk and cheese. I couldn’t separate these two Numan classics tbh, I love them both.

[TQR 14,396]

35 minutes ago, msc said:

Genuinely difficult to find one to give minus points to, tbh.

Yep. There’s only one song left on the list that I dislike, couple of others I don’t much care for but are certainly acceptable, the rest is brilliant. A lot of it better than the vast majority of previous round finalists, even.

[Death Impends 7,975]

47 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

47 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

42 Bee Gees - Night Fever

40 Blondie – Heart of glass

32 Gary Numan - Cars +4

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

27 Police – Message in a bottle

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

26 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap 

25 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick 

25 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

23 Blondie – Sunday Girl

22 ABBA – Take a chance on me 

21 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

6 Police – Walking on the moon -3

0 Pink Floyd - Another Brick in the Wall -3

 

Police are a mixed bag for me, I think the songs themselves are pretty good but the vocals are somewhat doofy. Not to the point I can't enjoy the songs, but it does make them do relatively less for me in a strong batch.

[Toast 16,140]

Surprised at the unpopularity of Another Brick In The Wall.   I love it. 

Didn't realise there were so many teachers on here.

[time 8,602]

49 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights +2

49 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking +2

42 Bee Gees - Night Fever

40 Blondie – Heart of glass

32 Gary Numan - Cars

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

28 Bee Gees – Tragedy

27 Police – Message in a bottle

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

26 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap 

25 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick 

25 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

23 Blondie – Sunday Girl

22 ABBA – Take a chance on me 

21 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

0 Police – Walking on the moon -6

 

[time 8,602]

As I said earlier, Walking on the Moon isn't one of my preferred Police tracks (they arrive in the 80s).

 

I managed to get down to a top 7 before struggling to decide which should go (3 are already gone). Of the remainder there are 5 or 6 I wouldn't miss if I never heard them again.

[Drewsky1211 4,744]

49 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

49 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

42 Bee Gees - Night Fever

40 Blondie – Heart of glass

32 Gary Numan - Cars

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

29 Bee Gees – Tragedy +1

27 Police – Message in a bottle

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

25 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap -1 

25 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick 

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive +3

23 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday -2

22 ABBA – Take a chance on me 

20 Blondie – Sunday Girl -3

 

[ladyfiona 2,585]

52 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights +3

47 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking -2

42 Bee Gees - Night Fever

40 Blondie – Heart of glass

32 Gary Numan - Cars

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

29 Bee Gees – Tragedy

27 Police – Message in a bottle

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

25 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

25 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick 

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 ABBA – Take a chance on me +1

20 Blondie – Sunday Girl

19 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday -4

[Clorox Bleachman 2,432]

3 hours ago, TQR said:

This is a fascinating use of points given they’re not exactly chalk and cheese. I couldn’t separate these two Numan classics tbh, I love them both.

 

Well I don't!

 

Actually that's a bit harsh, Cars is obviously an important song in electronic history, I just enjoy Are "Friends" Electric? more in every measurable way. There's so much great and diverse music in this round and I don't want another situation where there are 4 similar-sounding ABBA songs blocking everything else. It might look bad giving -6 to a perfectly fine song though.

[RIP Wee Jum 1,559]

52 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

51 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking +4

42 Bee Gees - Night Fever

40 Blondie – Heart of glass

32 Gary Numan - Cars

30 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star 

29 Bee Gees – Tragedy

27 Police – Message in a bottle

26 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric 

25 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

25 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick 

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 ABBA – Take a chance on me

14 Blondie – Sunday Girl -6

19 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday

[Toast 16,140]

52 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

51 Althea & Donna – Up Town Top Ranking

42 Bee Gees - Night Fever

40 Blondie – Heart of glass

32 Gary Numan - Cars

30 Tubeway Army – Are “Friends” Electric   +4

29 Bee Gees – Tragedy

27 Police – Message in a bottle

25 The Boomtown Rats – Rat Trap

25 Ian Dury & the Blockheads – Hit me with your rhythm stick 

24 The Buggles - Video Killed the Radio Star   -6

24 Gloria Gaynor – I will survive

23 ABBA – Take a chance on me

14 Blondie – Sunday Girl

19 10CC – Dreadlock Holiday